One of the most common objections raised against Lancastrian theonomy is that its appeal to case law smuggles legislation in through the back door. If judges apply God’s law to new situations, the critic says, then they are really creating new law, and case law turns out to be just stare decisis or legislating under another name. This episode answers that charge.
The objection collapses once you see where biblical case law actually begins. God has already legislated. His law is fixed, settled, and sufficient. Stare decisis binds a judge to the rulings of the judges before him, so that human precedent stacks on human precedent until the law is whatever the courts have piled up over time. Biblical case law is nothing like that. The judge does not make law and he is not chained to a line of prior opinions. He makes diligent inquiry and renders a verdict in the specific case before him, measured against the standard of God’s Word. A verdict decides that case. It does not become a new statute binding every case after it.






